I feel a bit like this is a thread hijack, but ... I had a r12r LC for 2 days in Santa Fe. What a fun bike! and I missed it greatly when I got back on my 09 roadster to head home.
Decided to get a new bike.
A few things sold me on the GS vs the R12r.
To outfit the roadster with a good screen, looking at over $100 at least, likely lots more. The GS comes with one, and it adjusts!
I wanted handguards, an accessory on the roadster. Common on the GS, don't know if it's standard, but it's on ALL of them
I really don't like the bulbous looking bags on the roadster. The GS has the Varios, squared and more eye appeal to me.
I thought I would like the blue color far more than I did. I liked the colors on the GS.
The BiG RED R is too much. I could live with it for sure, but not the styling I'd do. No Black or near black. It's the absence of color.
I thought I could farkle the GS more easily logistically than the roadster. I've had two roadsters and I realized that on each one, setting it up for the travel I do, made it kinda like a GS. And it was expensive to do. There was less to do on the GS.
There were things I wanted for the roadster that weren't available yet, but were on the GS
And the dash was better on the GS! It has an analog speedo AND an analog tach.
Some of that is pretty fuzzy, I agree. And, if I could not find the proper GS, I knew I would be happy on the roadster, but with the lowered suspension, I thought the GS was just too appealing, even at its premium price.
Having had the GS now for a couple of months, highway, city, rough streets, twisties, long straights, I love it. It's SO comfortable! More so than the roadster because of the GS's more upright position and slightly greater seat to peg distance. I would have been happy on the roadster, but I know I am happier on the GS.
And I LIKE the way it looks...all insectoid 'n $heet! Maybe an acquired taste, but I like it! And I LIKE the Racing Red, And I like the 19" front wheel, makes a big difference in handling. And I like the wide bars. The roadsters bars I believe--could be wrong--are narrower and maybe that leads to the quicker steering feel? But I like the more behaved front end with wider bars.
And it's very fast, loves the turns.
Again, I know I would be happy with the roadster, but when all is said and done, I would have paid to equip it enough to get closer to the GS price. May be my imagination, or wishful thinking, but as fine as the fit and finish of the roadster is (and it is and that's what really separates it from its competition in my view), as fine as it is, I think it's a bit better on the GS.
And finally, totally personal maybe, but there is a mystique about the GS that the roadster doesn't have. It has some of it, cuz it's a beemer, but the GS has more. And I think GS riders know it. Not that they feel smug about their bike, but they know it's something special in the bike world.
Both great bikes for sure. But I knew within 1300 miles, this bike was a better fit for me. Obviously, ymmv, and this IS a roadster forum. I realize that, but as the title was "vs all other rivals," well, that includes the GS to me. I chose it over the roadster. Different strokes.